Becoming a Shingle Selection Guru

Color selection is easy. But shingle brand selection? A bit harder!


MY MISSION: By the end of this blog post, you'll be a pro at selecting the right roof for your home!


But here's the quick summary if you don't have time to read the whole article...


ARCHITECTURAL ASPHALT SHINGLES

  • GOOD: GAF HDZ

  • BETTER: Certainteed Landmark Pro

  • BEST: Owens Corning Duration (includes Duration "Designer")


source: 2025 Shingle Olympics — https://youtu.be/uxvNH_kZJMY?si=uutwxjH6P76vMoAG

(disregard Malarky since they're made for blizzard weather and not sold in the Carolinas)



METAL PANELS

  • BETTER: Tuff-Rib (Rugged but Economical)

  • BEST: Standing Seam (Gorgeous but Pricey)



To become a shingle selection guru, and for an unbiased scientific review of how all shingles compare to one another, please watch the “Shingle Olympics“ at:

https://youtu.be/uxvNH_kZJMY?si=uutwxjH6P76vMoAG


In the Shingle Olympics, shingles were analyzed by:

  • nailing zone

  • sealant strength

  • weight

  • impact resistance against hail and wind

  • asphalt grade

  • thickness

  • granule loss


THE TAKEAWAY

The right choice depends on what decision factors you value most...

  • Choose Owens Corning if performance and modern engineering matters more to you.

  • Choose Certainteed if appearance and visual depth matters more to you.

  • Choose GAF if budget matters more to you.



Oh and for metal... here are 10 reasons why you would choose a metal roof over asphalt shingles:

  1. Longevity

  2. Durability

  3. Leak Resistance

  4. Energy Efficiency

  5. Low Maintenance

  6. Fire Resistance

  7. Performance in Snow & Heavy Rain

  8. Higher Resale Perception

  9. Cooler Attic Temperatures

  10. Environmental Impact


Congratulations, you're now a Roof Selection Guru!


If knowledge is power (which you now have), then according to Spider-Man's Uncle Ben ("with great power comes great responsibility"), you are now "responsible" for choosing the future fate of your next roof! 😉

BUT WHAT COMES BEFORE COLOR AND TYPE SELECTION? A proper attic inspection!


Book your complimentary attic inspection today (link below), and yes of course we’ll throw in the less-important rooftop inspection as well…

Book via Google Calendar

Next
Next

The Attic Inspection, Optional or Critical?